Celebration or Sabotage?
ou hit a financial milestone and celebrated by spending. Now the milestone is gone. Here's why progress itself can become the thing that unravels it.
You hit a savings milestone. You paid off a credit card. You stuck to your budget for a whole month. Time to celebrate, right? So you buy yourself something nice, and just like that, you’re back below the milestone.
There’s a new balance on the card. The budget is blown for the month.
The celebration erased the achievement. And if this sounds familiar, it’s not because you lack discipline or because you’re having bad luck. It’s a pattern with a name: progress sabotage. About 42% of people report “undoing” their financial progress with the very spending that was supposed to mark it. So if this is happening to you, you’re in a very large, very quiet club.
The Progress Paradox
Researchers Ayelet Fishbach and Ravi Dhar discovered something that seems backwards at first. When people focus on how far they’ve come rather than how far they still have to go, they’re significantly more likely to make choices that run counter to their own goals. Over 30% more likely, in some studies.
“I’ve come so far.” feels great. But it also activates the same licensing effect we discussed in the first post in the series. The pride you feel in your progress quietly grants you permission to ease up. The more accomplished you feel, the more slack you give yourself.
This is why celebrating milestones can backfire so badly. The celebration is an acknowledgment of progress, and that acknowledgment is exactly what triggers the permission to undo it. Dieters who stop to congratulate themselves on weight lost tend to lose less weight going forward. Savers who throw themselves a spending party after reaching a goal tend to save less in the weeks that follow. The pride itself becomes the trapdoor.
Two Steps Forward, One and a Half Back
Here’s how the math plays out for a lot of people, and see if any of this rings true.
You work hard and save $500. That feels like a real accomplishment, so you celebrate with a $200 purchase. Now you have $300 saved, but it still feels like you saved $500 because that was the milestone, and the milestone is what you remember. So you push toward the next goal, hit it, celebrate again with another reward purchase, and then a few months later, you’re wondering why progress feels so impossibly slow.
The issue isn’t that you rewarded yourself. It’s that the reward was denominated in the same currency as the achievement. You’re paying for celebration with progress, and the math never works out in your favor.
Signposts vs. Rest Stops
None of this means you shouldn’t acknowledge your wins. Of course, you should. The question isn’t whether to mark an achievement, it’s how.
Think about it this way. A signpost on a road trip says, “You’ve come 50 miles.” You read it, feel good, and keep driving. A rest stop says, “Time to pull over and head back the way you came.” Same road, completely different relationship to the journey.
A healthy celebration is a signpost: acknowledgment without reversal. Problematic celebration is a rest stop: acknowledgment that undoes the forward motion.
A few questions that can help you tell which one you’re looking at before you commit:
Does this celebration require me to spend money I just saved?
Will I feel the same way about this purchase in a month, or will it have faded like so many others?
Is the reward size proportional to the milestone, or am I using the milestone as a permission slip for something I wanted anyway?
And maybe the most honest question of all: am I celebrating the achievement, or am I escaping the discipline that got me here?
The Real Achievement
The milestone isn’t the achievement itself. The person you became while reaching it is the one you are. The habits you built, the patience you practiced, and the identity shift that happened along the way. Those are the real wins.
When you celebrate by reverting to old spending patterns, you’re not rewarding the person who saved that money. You’re handing the keys back to the version of you that spent it. And research on identity-based goals backs this up: people who celebrate “being the kind of person who saves” show significantly less licensing behavior than people who celebrate “having saved a specific amount.” The framing matters more than most people realize.
So instead of asking, “What does the person who deprived themselves to save $500 deserve?” try asking, “What would the person who saved $500 choose to do next?”
Those two questions lead to very different places.
Before the Next Milestone
Before your next financial milestone arrives, decide now how you’ll acknowledge it. Write it down while your head is clear and the licensing effect hasn’t yet whispered in your ear. Pick something that honors the progress without reversing it.
And if you can’t think of anything that isn’t spending, what’s the point? That’s actually useful information. It might mean that what you’re really looking for isn’t a reward at all, but a moment of real pride in who you’re becoming. Sometimes that’s the only celebration the moment actually calls for.
Next in this series, we’ll dig into what you’re really looking for when you reach for the treat, because the purchase is almost never about the purchase.
This content is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or therapeutic advice. Consider speaking with qualified professionals for personalized guidance.
There’s still time to test the Monello app and get it free forever. Follow this post for instructions.